‘Heretic’ Costars Speak Portrayal of Mormonism After Rising Up in Church

Each of the lead actresses in Heretic grew up with Mormonism, however enjoying missionaries within the film was considerably of a coincidence.

As co-director Scott Beck informed Leisure Weekly in an interview printed Friday, Nov. 8, Sophie Thatcher and Chloe East — who play Sister Barnes and Sister Paxton, respectively, reverse Hugh Grant‘s villainous Mr. Reed within the A24 thriller — each had a non secular upbringing that “was not essentially on our bingo card once we had been casting.”

“We weren’t like, ‘Now we have to search out two actresses that had been raised Mormon,’ ” mentioned Beck, 40. “However the cause they gained the position is as a result of they had been so true after they carried out it. We stored going again to our casting director, asking, ‘Are there extra individuals like these two? As a result of there is a fact there.’ ”

East, 23, informed the outlet she “felt like I knew this character in my bones,” contemplating her private connection to the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

By no means miss a narrative — join PEOPLE’s free every day e-newsletter to remain up-to-date on the most effective of what PEOPLE has to supply​​, from superstar information to forcing human-interest tales.

“I want I did not understand it so nicely and I needed to analysis stuff, however I used to be like, ‘I bought it,’ ” she defined. “I, sadly, was this individual or have this individual within me that I can use on this film. However it is extremely good to have a task that does come considerably naturally.”

Thatcher recalled to EW that she felt an “prompt connection” to East since they each grew up in Mormon households.

“We discovered lots of parallels in our lives and related, and I feel they noticed that and noticed the truthfulness behind our connection to the faith,” added the Yellowjackets actress, 24.

Talking to Utah’s ABC4, Thatcher mentioned she “simply considered my cousins” and likewise “requested my mother lots of questions” whereas making ready.

“Chloe is much more in contact, so I bought lots of suggestions from her, and appeared up her associates. She would present me her associates’ Instagram,” she added. “So I used to be like, that is what a contemporary Mormon seems like, and it’s so regular. There’s so many ranging levels of it.”

As East informed EW, Heretic offers a distinct tackle portraying Mormonism.

“You at all times see very excessive takes — The Guide of Mormon musical and even Underneath the Banner of Heaven is a really particular form of excessive Mormonism mentality and excessive,” mentioned East. “I do know lots of Mormon associates who take a look at that collection, and so they’re like, ‘We’re not like that. That is bizarre. That isn’t us.’ After which you’ve a extra truthful, extra present, trendy model of Mormonism that lots of my associates establish with. And also you simply do not see that quite a bit. You do not see this model of Mormonism performed out.”

In Heretic, Mr. Reed (Grant, 64) seems innocent at first, welcoming two missionaries from the LDS Church into his dwelling. However as Sisters Barnes and Paxton try to convert him to their faith, they change into enmeshed in a psychologically twisted check of religion.

The PEOPLE Puzzler crossword is right here! How shortly are you able to remedy it? Play now!

In a dialog with GQ printed earlier this month, Beck’s filmmaking companion and co-director, Bryan Woods, mentioned Thatcher and East “needed to maintain all the pieces grounded” of their performances, and “discover that authenticity that they know.”

“Chloe has associates to this present day which are missionaries on missions proper now, so she was texting them whereas we had been filming,” added Woods, 40.

As for Thatcher, he mentioned she “left the church earlier in her life” and “has members of the family which are out and in,” which “positively helped layer her efficiency as Sister Barnes.”

“[The character is] any person who grew up within the church however has this lingering query of, ‘Is it actual?’ or ‘Do I slot in right here?’ and ‘What do I consider?’ ” Woods added.

Heretic is in theaters now.