Lady Refuses to be Sister’s Maid of Honor As a result of She Missed Her Marriage ceremony After Canine Died

• A lady shared on Reddit that she has turned down her older sister’s request to be maid of honor in her wedding ceremony
• Her cause is that her sister missed her personal wedding ceremony final yr on account of her canine dying
• “Whereas I really like her, I simply couldn’t fake like every thing was positive,” the Redditor wrote

A lady is questioning if she’s mistaken for refusing to be her sister’s maid of honor after she missed her personal wedding ceremony final yr on account of her canine dying.

The 28-year-old girl defined the scenario in a publish on Reddit‘s “Am I the A——” discussion board, starting by offering some background. She stated she acquired married final yr in a “small however lovely ceremony with our closest household and associates.” Her 32-year-old sister, with whom she has “an advanced relationship,” was presupposed to function her maid of honor.

“We’re shut, however she’s additionally extraordinarily emotional and sort of dramatic,” the OP (authentic poster) famous.

She then claimed that two days earlier than her wedding ceremony, her older sister’s 14-year-old canine died unexpectedly — one thing that she was “clearly sympathetic” about, however affected her sister considerably.

“She known as me sobbing, saying she couldn’t emotionally deal with coming to the marriage as a result of she was too devastated,” the OP recalled. “I attempted to speak her down, even supplied to have somebody carry her residence early if it was an excessive amount of, however she refused and didn’t present up.”

The OP stated not having her sister at her wedding ceremony “harm lots.”

“She missed one of many greatest days of my life, and I had no maid of honor,” she stated. “We didn’t discuss a lot after that.”

By no means miss a narrative — join PEOPLE’s free each day e-newsletter to remain up-to-date on the perfect of what PEOPLE has to supply​​, from movie star information to forcing human curiosity tales.

Now, it is the OP’s sister’s flip to get married — and she or he has requested her youthful sibling to be her maid of honor. However the OP stated she refuses to tackle the function.

“I advised her I couldn’t. I stated I nonetheless felt harm she missed my wedding ceremony, and whereas I really like her, I simply couldn’t fake like every thing was positive,” she defined.

Her sister didn’t take it effectively, and her dad and mom additionally weighed in.

“She acquired extraordinarily upset, stated I used to be being chilly and petty, and that her canine was like her little one. Our dad and mom are pressuring me to only be the larger individual,” the OP concluded her publish, in search of recommendation and opinions from the Reddit group.

Within the feedback part, folks had combined reactions concerning the scenario, with some accusing the OP of desirous to skip her older sibling’s big day “out of spite.”

One reader argued that the OP’s sister “could not win, actually.”

“It was solely 2 days after her canine handed. She wasn’t prepared,” they wrote. “Both she skips your wedding ceremony and also you’re mad about that, or she involves your wedding ceremony, breaks down and finally ends up drawing consideration whether or not she actually intends to or not. You’d in all probability be even madder about that. The actual fact of the loss sucks, and the disruptive timing sucks, too.”

Different readers, nevertheless, shared the opinion that the OP’s sister ought to have attended her sister’s wedding ceremony regardless of the dying of her beloved pet.

“Some commentators assume dropping a 14 yr outdated canine is a justifiable cause for bailing on a sibling’s wedding ceremony. I feel that your sibling bailing in your wedding ceremony is a justifiable cause for feeling so let down by them that it damages your relationship with them,” one individual stated.

One other agreed, writing: “Proper? I’d’ve confirmed up for my sister.”